91 Comments

This is so raw and so real. And I"m so sorry this is your life (and the life of all of us going through this).

No parent deserves to have their child literally stolen from them by morally bankrupt activists while we are expected to cheer it on -- but that is what is happening. Sending good thoughts your way that your son turns it around in time.

Expand full comment

Oh my goodness! I read your opening paragraph and I had to do a double take wondering if I submitted this to PITT last year and forgot about it. I could have written this last year, verbatim. Same age, same actions… The anime female character name… Same as mine. Proof # 100 that this is a cult.

Expand full comment

Gender ideology and critical race theory often involved ILLEGAL discrimination! Here are some recent victories I had against critical race theory in education and employment. The NYC film fund, a 7-million-dollar film fund which only helped upcoming artists if they wish to live as women, is now open to both sexes regardless of sexual orientation and gender identity because I complained to NYSDHR and they were found to have done illegal discrimination. I gathered evidence and filed complaints with NYSDHR and other FEPAs in other states, as well as OCR. Read my article to learn what my some of my victories are. https://open.substack.com/pub/justingaffneysamuels/p/using-factual-evidence-and-the-law?r=6512g&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Expand full comment

I feel like you wrote this just for, except in my case I’m the dad and it’s my daughter who’s been stolen. Thank you so much for expressing what this nightmare feels like. And if you pray at all, our daughter has been on testosterone for 6 months and told us recently she’s scheduled to have top surgery in January. Helpless isn’t even close to adequate to describe how we’re feeling.

Expand full comment

Nothing anyone can write can mend the broken thing. I’m so filled with rage that this is happening whilst everyone sleeps. I am a mother and a mother’s heart knows best the cruelty and depravity of this movement. I’m sorry.

Expand full comment

You hit many familiar notes for me. It's all so tragic, this unique and constant state of loss. I hope the light shines through for you eventually.

Expand full comment

My husband and I are on a lovely trip….in order to avoid the upcoming holiday……we are traveling with others, strangers who could be friends. I feel so detached, what do I say when people ask about my children? I can be having an ok day, enjoying what is in front of me when someone asks about my kids. Instantly transported to pain and grief….my husband, and sometimes I, hates what this has done to our lives. He doesn’t want to talk about it anymore and I get it I totally get it. I wish it weren’t on my mind all the time, but every day I wake up I remember…..😢

Expand full comment

Poignant, touching, heartrending. Thank you for your honesty and openness. It was difficult to read because it brought back so many memories of my son who is no longer with us. My thoughts are with you and your family. I wish the very best outcome for you all. Sincerely, Frederick

Expand full comment

I feel every single one of these points. What is striking is how similar your description is with my experiences with my son and in my family. My son was older when he decided to transition, and it felt like it came out of the blue, but there had been many years of challenges before that-depression, undiagnosed and untreated neuroatypicality etc. When this first came into my family, it was so lonely and disorienting. There was so much cultural noise (What is the root of all of this? How did we get here?) and personal noise (The pools and puddles of guilt/hope that you dip and drown in as a parent) to sort through. Hearing other people talk about like this has helped immensely. Now three years in, I know more and I understand more. I am grateful to every single person that has contributed to that-including writing like this. But, I still have moments of deep, deep emotion-the moments you described so well. Those rage, grief, fear and sorrow moments that tumble me head over heels. The reality is that the person I love is hurting the person that I love-and where can your anger go then? For a while my anger went to the institutions and organizations that are allowing this madness to float unchecked in their currents and eddies-or worse actively promoting it without counting the cost to bodies and minds. Having a place to focus my anger felt good, but, I don't want to get stuck in anger or sadness. Ultimately, I know I need to focus on the things that are in my control, in my sphere of influence-everybody's is different and I think it changes over time. I have my role as a parent of an adult, my role in the institutions that I inhabit, my role as a consumer of social and cultural artifacts-media, internet, movies and television. I can tell you that this experience has made me think more deeply about all of those roles. As much as it is painful, that is one positive thing.

Expand full comment

Yes, yes, yes. Total identification. You named some stings and rages that I, too, feel, but hadn't yet articulated. Like rage at Planned Parenthood (I used to make donations to them!), and gladness that my late mother and father never saw my daughter pretending to be a runty little man . . .

Expand full comment

That blessed moment of waking up and thinking, even for a second, that all was right with the world? It reminds me of the weeks after my dad died after struggling for years with Alzheimers. The parallels aren't exact, of course. My dad went when it was his time, and we who survived him all felt some relief. Should my child decide to proceed with transition in some form, it won't be a death - though I understand why so many parents feel it as such. But I wonder if I will ever be able to wake up without the crush of grief and fear that is now the prelude to my coffee every day. You spoke to that so well.

Dear mama, I hope you can stay connected to your child. I hope he will find his way back to his actual authentic self, not this simulacrum. Hold fast to your love, as much as it hurts.

Expand full comment

Oh, Mama, God Bless you - even if religion is not a part of your life. I just feel the pain of the universe in which you are living. This insidious cult is so sick. It is wrong. YOU are right. I do believe that our society has done a great job of convincing our youth, especially if they are white, that they are bad, they are racist, they are privileged - and that the only way to make it right is to become a 'minority'. To come one of the oppressed. Only then can they lead a life worthy of living. This is SO off kilter. What ARE we doing?!! Please know that you are heard.

Expand full comment

I'm so very sorry.

Expand full comment

I am so sorry for what you are going through; I will keep you in my prayers; and I will continue to do what I can along with others to enable people to see the damage done by this ideology.

Expand full comment

"dive into the trans agenda: the wrong sex hormones, the awful stereotyped wardrobe, and, in another kick in the gut, changing his name to an anime female character's." - Sounds like a middle-aged man I'm acquainted with, only he chose the wardrobe and name of a main character from The Hunger Games franchise. It's literally cringeworthy to view. He looks nothing like a woman and his chosen last name makes me feel bad for his family.

Expand full comment

I wish I could say otherwise, but this is such a sad story.

I'm so very sorry for your family's challenges and loss.

But your family's story is very instructive for others - thanks so much for sharing it.

Expand full comment